Fan Fiction
This story has been set to a rating of NC-17. Age verification is required to proceed.
I Write Sins Not Tragedies – Chapter 11 Part two
Chapter 11 part 2
"Uhh!" Carmen moaned as Helena’s mouth latched on to her clit and sucked. Alice had set a ringing timer on her watch so she could watch along with everyone else, who seemed to be in a trance.
Helena made a loud slurping sound with her mouth and Carmen let out a small scream. Carmen suddenly gasped and gripped onto Jenny’s shoulder. Jenny who had managed to remain calm started trembling. Shane soothed her arm gently.
"Oh God, I’m gonna cum!" Carmen whimpered arching up, "I’m gonna cummmmmaaaaahhhhhh!!!"
Helena gripped Carmen’s hips as she arched and started trembling.
"Holy fucking shit!" Jenny cried as Carmen’s grip on her shoulder tightened so tight it was leaving a bruise. Alice’s jaw dropped as her watch beeped. Helena had beat the challenge.
"Shit," Bette said grabbing a bottle of water.
"Oh man, I’m scared of what I’ll get," Tina murmured.
Helena stood up slowly and wiped her mouth. Carmen, still breathing heavily lifted up her pants and flopped herself back down on the couch. "Sorry for hurting you Jenny," she said.
"It’s alright," Jenny said as Shane started kissing her new bruise, "Shane will make it better."
"She won’t even remember it’s there," Shane murmured kissing Jenny’s cheek lovingly.
Dana grinned and closed Alice’s jaw. "Next contestant Helena?"
"Carmen."
"You won’t even let me recover?" Carmen cried.
"Maybe you’ll get truth," Helena said.
"Psh very unlikely," Alice said having had recovered.
Carmen groaned and flicked the arrow. A smile graced her features.
Alice scowled, "truth."
"I knew it babe," Helena said rubbing Carmen’s thigh.
"Alright, what’s my question?" Carmen said.
"It’s a round robin question actually," Alice said, "you answer it first then it goes around the circle and everyone has to answer."
"Hey no fair!" Tina cried.
"All’s fair in love and Alice’s games," Alice said.
"It’s war, Alice," Bette said in annoyance, "all’s fair in love and war."
"Well I don’t believe in war so I adjusted it," Alice said.
"Oh come on already, what’s my question!" Carmen laughed.
"Other than your partner," Alice read, "who would you love to kiss?"
Carmen glanced at Tina for a moment then said, "Shane."
"Really?" Shane said in surprise.
"Okay, round robin, go!" Alice said.
"I would like to kiss Tina," Helena said honestly.
"I would like to kiss you Alice," Jenny said.
"Me??" Alice cried.
"Em, I’d go for Bette," Shane said.
"I’d choose Jenny, I guess," Tina said.
Bette cleared her throat and said, "Dana."
"Well you got close enough," Dana teased. "Well I would choose Carmen."
Everyone looked at Alice. "Um, well I…er…"
"Spill it moderator!" Helena teased.
"We can tease you just as bad Al," Jenny added.
"I would just love to do that," Bette said.
"Okay, alright! Alright!" Alice whined. "I would choose Helena."
"Oh bugger," Helena muttered.
"Did everyone basically choose everyone?" Carmen asked.
"Yeah I think so," Tina said.
"I like truth," Bette said nervously, "we should have more of those."
"True dat," Dana said in a terrible gangster tone.
Everyone burst out laughing.
"Okay," Carmen said once they settled down, "I choose Tina to go next."
"Oh man," Tina moaned leaning forward and flicking the arrow.
"Yippikaiyay!" Alice cheered, "dare!"
"Uh oh," Bette said.
"It’s a sudden death round," Alice said.
"What?" Tina cried.
"Whoever gets the green paper has to make out with you for two minutes," Alice said.
Everyone practically lunged forward to grab a paper from the hat. Tina blushed and said, "gee, I feel so loved."
"Aw dammit!" Alice cried looking at her red paper, "who has it! Who has it!"
"I do," Jenny said lifting her paper.
Tina flushed.
"Looks like you’re getting your wish, you said you wanted to kiss her," Dana teased.
"N-not like that!" Tina stammered.
Jenny stood up and took a deep breath. She walked to Tina and sat down beside her. Bette and Shane’s eyes were glued to the scene as tentatively they leaned forward and kissed each other.
Alice clicked her watch. The kissing was slow and gentle, not much tongue and not very passionate. Bette and Shane couldn’t help but sigh in relief. By the end of the first minute Tina and Jenny were getting bored.
They became a little playful slowly rubbing their tongues together and licking all around the inside of each other’s mouths.
"Jesus that’s messy," Dana commented.
"Aaaaand TIME!" Alice shrieked.
Tina and Jenny broke apart then started laughing. "You’re a very good kisser Jenny, but," Tina said, "nothing."
"Goes to show we’re not meant to be," Jenny said returning to her seat.
"Well you both have proved you got tongue skill," Alice teased, "I bet Shane and Bette love it."
This earned her a harsh glare from both couples as Dana, Helena, and Carmen laughed.
"You know what?" Tina said, "just for that, I choose Alice to go next."
"Me?" Alice squeaked.
"Yep, now flick!" Tina said in her commanding voice.
Everyone laughed when Alice submissively leaned forward and flicked the arrow.
"Dare," Dana said.
"I’ll read it," Shane said jumping forward. "Your partner can choose any other player to grope you and go to second base. You cannot argue or deny."
"W-what! What kind of dare is that?" Alice cried.
"You wrote them Al," Bette pointed out.
"Dana," Tina said, "be smart about this. Choose very carefully."
"Yeah choose someone who annoys the hell out of Alice," Helena said.
"Someone who bothers her to the core," Carmen added.
"Someone who’s touch would be enough to punish her indirectly for all the horrible things we’ve had to do tonight," Jenny said.
"Remember, she made you masturbate in front of everyone," Shane said.
"And dommes don’t like feeling vulnerable," Bette said.
"Be gentle," Alice squeaked.
Dana smirked and looked around the room. She knew exactly which person would drive Alice up the wall, maybe even piss her off. It was the perfect dare, a perfect case of karma.
"I choose Jenny," Dana said.
Everyone laughed as Alice’s face contorted in horror.
"What am I a whore?" Jenny whined, "I’ve had the most action tonight."
"I don’t know," Carmen said, "Dana and I were the only ones so far to have orgasms."
"I chose you because I know you two are basically archenemies," Dana said, "I know you will torture her."
A wicked grin spread across Jenny’s face. "Oh it will," she purred, "shirt off Al."
"Oh man!" Alice whined lifting her shirt off her head and unhooking her bra.
Once topless, Jenny climbed on top of her and grabbed Alice’s full breasts in her hands. She squeezed them gently then started rolling the nipples with her palms. Everyone started snickering when Alice dropped her head back and made a whining noise.
Jenny smirked and leaned down to take a nipple into her mouth. Alice’s eyes shot open and a low moan escaped her lips. Everyone let out loud laughs as Alice flushed in embarrassment.
Jenny sucked on the nipple hard before taking it in between her teeth and tugging. "Jjjjjeeeesssuuussss!" Alice cried.
"Do the trick Jen," Shane said, "you know, the one I like."
"Uh oh," Tina teased, "watch out Alice."
Jenny obeyed and started doing her move where she sucked the nipple hard while at the same time scraping her teeth over the hardened nub.
"Oh my God!" Alice cried, "how the hell are you doing that!!!"
Jenny suddenly backed away, shrugged teasingly and walked back to her seat.
"Oh she’s a cheeky one," Helena said.
"I wonder how you manage her Shane," Tina said.
"The same way I manage Alice," Dana said handing her her shirt, "punishments."
"Well who do you choose Alice?" Tina asked.
"Well since I can’t choose Jenny as payback, I choose Shane," Alice said.
"I ain’t scared," Shane said with a shrug, leaning forward and flicking the arrow.
"Truth you lucky bastard," Alice said slipping on her shirt.
Shane smirked.
"Well at least it’s another round robin," Alice said, "where’s the craziest place you’ve ever been fucked? And it’s not where you have fucked, it’s where you’ve BEEN fucked."
"Alright I get it!" Shane laughed. "Eh, well Bette and Tina’s kitchen table."
"Eww Shane we eat there!" Tina whined. With a sigh she continued, "craziest place I have been fucked was the back of my father’s truck while he was in the front seat driving."
"Oh shit," Alice laughed.
"For me it was the top of the Empire State Building," Bette said.
"How the hell did you manage that!?" Helena cried.
"The question was where not how," Bette said with a sly smile.
"For me it was behind the bleachers during a break in my tennis match against Serena Williams," Dana said.
"Is that how you managed to beat her?" Shane teased.
Dana blushed, "no I totally got lucky, her arm was sore from over training."
"Hey you beat Serena Williams, enjoy the moment," Alice said, "I do, you beat because I…relaxed you."
"Shut up Alice," Dana said shaking her head.
"Heh, well for me it was on the roof Helena’s car during the forth of July firework show," Alice said.
"Okay, I’m getting a new car," Helena said in disgust, "bloody hell."
"Uh, well, for me was in the pilot booth on a plane," Carmen said smirking.
"What!!!"
"Who was flying the plane?"
"Was the pilot a girl cause you rarely see that?"
Carmen laughed, "ladies, ladies, hang on there. The pilot was a girl, the co-pilot flew the plane, and he didn’t even notice what went on behind him."
"Oh that’s insane!" Bette laughed.
"For me it was the top of Big Ben," Helena said, "like in between the machinery."
"Can people even go in there?" Jenny asked.
Helena smirked and said, "no."
Everyone said at the same time "whoa!" They sounded like the green aliens from ‘Toy Story.’
"I can’t beat Big Ben, but the craziest place for me was during the ‘Tilt-a-Whirl’ at the LA County Fair," Jenny said.
Everyone laughed and Tina said, "Damn Shane, that’s some skill."
Shane grinned smugly.
"Alright the last person to go is Bette," Alice said.
"Oh man, why do I have the feeling that I’m gonna get the worse one," Bette muttered as she flicked the arrow.
"Dare," Alice said, "ooo."
"See? What did I say?" Bette said dropping her head.
Alice smirked and read the slice, "’your partner must wear a strap on stay still while you suck on it for two minutes then ride it for 20 whole minutes or until you cum, whichever comes first."
"Oh my God!" Bette cried.
"Damn that is definitely the worse dare!" Shane laughed.
"That’s why it’s the darkest blue on the board," Alice said smirking, "but if you don’t want to do it Bette, I’ll gladly tease the hell out of you."
Bette stood up angrily and stomped towards the bedroom saying, "no I’ll do it! Anything to shut you up."
Tina gulped and said, "c-can I touch her?"
"No," Alice said with a wicked smile, "like Shane in Jenny’s dare, you are not allowed to touch her."
"This is torture," Tina said.
"If you need me to hold your hands down let me know," Shane said.
Bette walked back into the room stark naked with a strap on in her hand. Everyone gasped and looked at her as she handed Tina the strap on.
Tina pulled down her pants and tied the strap on over her panties. She sat back down and tried to control her breath as Bette sank down to her knees.
"Alright, two minutes," Alice said clicking her watch.
Bette gripped the toy and held it as she leaned down and took it into her mouth. Slowly she started bobbing her head getting more and more of dildo with each bob.
Tina watched her and tried to keep control by clenching her fists. It took all her willpower to grip Bette’s hair and fuck her face.
"Two minutes are up," Alice said her voice cracking betraying her obvious arousal.
Bette stood up slowly and straddled Tina’s lap. Tina’s breathing picked up and she let out a little whimper. It was obvious to everyone that Tina hated not having control over the situation, she was groaning and trembling as Bette lowered herself onto the toy.
Bette moaned erotically in Tina’s ear and started grinding up and down. "Ohh God," Tina moaned, "Shane I think you need to hold my hands down!"
"You can touch her!" Alice cried, she was sweating profusely. "For God’s sake you can touch her!"
With a growl Tina grabbed Bette’s hips and roughly slammed her down onto the dildo. Bette cried out and grabbed on to Tina’s shoulders.
Bette rode her as hard as she could moaning and trembling. Tina moaned along with her gripping her hips so tight it was leaving marks.
Then it happened.
Bette threw her head back and moaned loudly. Her body started trembling and Tina held her close as she collapsed on top of her.
"Holy mother of God! We gotta go!" Shane cried grabbing Jenny’s hand and running out of the house.
"Alice I love this game!" Helena said grabbing Carmen’s hand and guiding her towards the door, "I love this game."
"Um, we’ll leave you to finish," Dana said picking up the pizza board and helping Alice out.
Once alone Tina looked at Bette and said, "I don’t think I can survive today."
"What do you mean baby?" Bette said breathlessly.
"Well it’s 12:07," Tina said, "Happy Birthday."
Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.


this story is soo crazy and hhhhooootttt thanks!!!
Wow this is insanity ladies!! I love it! Bette’s birthday. Leggo.
omg that was great… yay yay Bettes b-day and Tina cant wait does that mean Bette gets to take charge in the next chapter. Oh I hope so.. PLS POST ASAP!! love this story ladies u are doing a awesome job.
Crazy.PPS
Damn that was so hot!
You gals are doing an awesome job thanks for the great update.
This story is absolutely awesome! thank you.