Fan Fiction
This story has been set to a rating of . Age verification is required to proceed.
Loving Annabelle , Alternate Ending, Fiction Contest
Tears gathered behind her eyelids and clung heavily for a moment before spilling down her cheeks. She wept silently, defeated. Her eyes opened to gentle fingers fluttering on her cheek. Annabelle was looking at her intently.
“Annabelle this will never happen again” she spoke the awful words in a rush before Annabelle could speak first. “You need to leave right now”. Annabelle’s wounded look was almost more than she could bear.
“Simone, don’t do this” Annabelle said quietly.
“Don’t make this hard. You have to get dressed and go right now.”
“You said you loved me,” Annabelle was pleading now and she hated herself for it.
Simone closed her eyes so she wouldn’t have to see the hurt in Annabelle’s face, “just words said in the moment” she lied, “I didn’t mean them.”
The parallel moment in the dining room scene is more or less the same but Cat does not make the comment about Annabelle probably being in Miss Bradley’s room. It’s sweet Collins who says something to Mother Immaculata out of her genuine concern that Annabelle is missing. She does it innocently and hasn’t noticed that Simone isn’t at breakfast either. But Immaculata is quick and she does notice…… cut to the shoes on the stairs and the bedroom door opening. Simone and Annabelle are caught sitting in the bed half dressed now where they are still having their difficult conversation and both have been crying. “Simone! In my office right now!”
Simone and Mother Em have it out like they do in the film, but she doesn’t call the Fed agents. She needs time to pray about this and to consult with Father Harris.
“In the meantime I am moving the Tillman girl to another dormitory and you are not to speak with her again. I may call her mother. I may yet ask you to resign your post. You will know of my decisions within a week. At least no one else at the school knows. Leave me now, Simone. I must pray about this. You have greatly disappointed me.”
Simone walked slowly back to her room. In the space of one hour she had hurt the two most important women in her life. It was more than she could bear. She wanted to tell Aunt Em not too worry, that she would never speak with Annabelle again, that she had already told Annabelle so, that goddamit she’d give up love once again to protect the school, but the words stuck in her throat. She wouldn’t say those words ever again.
As she walked she felt all her hopes dry up, felt her heart closing up like a steel airless vault. This was her life now, what she had chosen for her future. She gave a short bitter laugh at the irony. For, in that second she knew that she would be leaving St. Teresa’s for good even if Aunt Em decided she could stay. She would go from this place forever, but not with Annabelle. The hollowness in her soul swallowed her up. Once again, she had not chosen love when she’d been given the chance. She had chosen this, to be alone.


Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.