Fan Fiction
This story has been set to a rating of R. Age verification is required to proceed.
17 Reasons Why… (Chapter 4)
“God, Tina, don’t you get it?” Alice locked eyes with her friend. “Listen to me very carefully, because I’m only going to say this once. Bette didn’t choose Jodi over you, Bette is chasing Jodi because she thinks you don’t want her.”
“What?” Tina asked, squinting her eyes as she tried to make sense of what Alice had just told her. Tina pushed herself quickly up from the sand, her agitation clear at the turn this conversation had taken.
“I told you, I’m not repeating it.” Alice chastised, a bit defensively. “Bette is going to kill me when she finds out I told you that much.”
“Alice, did Bette actually tell you that?” Tina questioned, her mind spinning into overdrive. “Did she say exactly what you just said?”
“Well, not exactly that, no.” Alice admitted sheepishly. “But it’s what she meant.”
“What did Bette say, exactly, that gave you that impression?” Tina pushed, not only relieved to be turning the interrogation tables on Alice, but more importantly, consumed by the need to find out if there was even the slightest chance that Bette could still have feelings for her.
“It’s more what she hasn’t said.” Alice explained, a hint of defensiveness creeping into her tone. “I keep telling her that you want her back, and she…”
“You keep telling her what?” Tina interrupted harshly, burying her hands in her hair.
“That you want her back?” Alice’s tone was meek, as she nervously flashed a fake grin. “I mean, you do, right? Want her back?”
“God, Alice, you know I do.” Tina admitted after drawing in a deep breath. “But why would you tell her that when she was finally happy with Jodi?”
“I’m not going to dignify that with a response, T.” Alice shot back, tilting her head to the side in disbelief.
“Whatever. That’s not the point.” Tina rolled her eyes again. “Now, what did she say exactly?”
“She just keeps dwelling on the fact that you can’t possibly want her back, because if you did, you wouldn’t be helping her with Jodi.” Alice explained with a sigh. “It’s like she can’t even open herself up to the possibility that you might want her back because she can’t handle being rejected like that again.”
“You know, Al, I’ve tried to talk to her about my feelings.” Tina offered after a brief silence. “I told her I’d rather deal with her control freak tendencies than boring Henry. I’ve told her I regretted leaving. She never gave me even the slightest indication that any of it mattered. What was I supposed to do?”
“You were supposed to fight for her, T.” Alice replied defiantly. “Remember how you told me before that you just wanted her to fight for you when you told her you were having feelings for men? That’s what she needed from you. Not just passing hints, but actual, real declarations that she was the one you really wanted. It’s been a long time since she’s gotten that from you, Tina.”
“Fuck.” Tina mumbled under her breath. She felt as though someone had just turned on the lights, and everything was starting to fit together. She knew she’d destroyed Bette when she told her she was having feelings for men. On some subconscious level, it was probably part of the reason she told her to begin with. Short of actually cheating, it was the closest thing she could do to make Bette feel every bit of pain she’d felt when she saw Bette’s hand graze the carpenter’s. But in recent months, she and Bette had been getting along so well, and she thought had been communicating so much better, that it never occurred to her that Bette could still be trying to protect herself.
“Fuck.” She repeated more emphatically. “Alice, are you sure?”
“Yeah, T., I’m sure.” Alice confirmed with the smallest hint of a smile. “She told me she kissed you this afternoon.” Alice offered with a soft laugh. “She was so freaked out that she upset you. She was scared that she’d violated your relationship with Kate. She didn’t once mention Jodi in that conversation. There’s no way that Porter doesn’t want you. Trust me. It was all about you.”
(To Be Continued…)
Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.



(2 votes, average: 3.50 out of 5)
I’m surprised Alice didn’t knock on Tina’s head and ask if anyone was home in there. lol
GO ALICE!!! I love that her big mouth is actually doing some good here! It’s about time someone helps the communication between these two, tells it like it is, and gets them back together! Gotta love Alice! Thanks Steph, you deserve some dancin’ cows for this!
thanks to Alice!!
Brilliantly written – IC alludes to this but you make it real thank god for Alice as Lamentamini said “I’m surprised Alice didn’t knock on Tina’s head and ask if anyone was home in there. lol ” Your writing was absolutely wonderful. Now get into action Tina and fast!!!
if only, if only, if only. i am of course referencing if only we were to be so fortunate to see just a snippet of something like this S4/S5, but alas, no. thanks for waking Tina up and allowing her to see what we’ve all wanted her to get all along. so looking forward to the next update!
For once Alice is making complete sense, Bette and Tina need to start listening to each other and thier own hearts.
Well Steph if you were writing the S5 episodes, you know you’d have the option to make Jenny drown on the little life raft she set sail on in S4. Just saying…….
Way to go Alice!!
Finally, some glimpse of light in the tunnel. Gotta love Alice… jesus fucking christ is right. Those two are exhausting! Can’t wait for your next chapter to see what Tina actually does with her enlightened information.
I love, love Alice! Very well written and I can’t wait for the next chapter to see what Tina does next.
Steph, I only have one thing to say, if IC ever needs a writer, I sure hope you’re available. You have a knack at really pulling the story together like few can. Thank you so much for this, because so many of us would have loved to see it play out this way!!! PPS
I repeat, sledgehammer. Peter Gabriel sang about them back when. I’m glad Alice has wielded such on Tina’s thick skull. Tina, your turn. So what are you saying Steph? I was some kind of maitresse de ballet? You just stay on your toes and like it.
Steph, thanks for another brilliant chapter. I’m glad that Tina had the conversation with Alice, I can’t wait to see how she responds…
We all hope that this comes to past. Nothing would please my heart more. thanks for a wonderful chapter
Steph, I so your Alice. Glad dhe got through to Tina. Now what will Tina do? Thank you PPS
Finally, someone more specifically Alice let out the truth. I hope that it is not too late for Bette and Tina to repair if not build new roads to their life as a couple.
Thank you Alice. Open the blinds eyes please lol. Come on Tina, ring Bette now, have a talk with your love hum. Fight for her
hey funnyone, i love the ballet!!! would you pay to see me do a dance??? ok, steph. still the assumptions are all over the place. but when people are assuming, then the hearing becomes very selective. and add protecting ones self in the the mix, ya gotta a whole lot of fun. very much like lifes experiences. thanks.
Your defining of 17 reasons is so much better than IC’s. I felt that way through the whole season. Like hello are you two listening to each other. I’m with Alice, I so wanted to smack someone. Love this steph, keep it up.
This story is great! Please continue it soon.
do u two ever actually listen to each other? lol..I’ve had that thought about them since s1!!!!!! loving the intensity…pps
We love Alice and love your story thank you so much please post soon love
Great work :] That’s all really, that needs to be said.
Oh I love this story… thank god Bette and Tina have Alice and thank god WE have you! Please post soon!
Oh, from Alice’s mouth to God’s ear. Let’s hope Tina books a flight to NY and Alice calls Bette to tell her that Tina is on her way or Tina calls her. Thank God for Alice’s big mouth and her tendency to impose herself into their situation. Maybe someone can get throughto the two of them. PPS
Lovely. If only IC makes this happen. Love this Steph. And Alice, you go girl!
Steph, As i read this I thought back to the scenes from the show. How did B & T become so clueless when it comes to reading the body language of the other? Wonderful job using Alice & her big mouth to finally point Tina in the right direction. Now, go get your woman, T! LOL! PS
thank goddess for alice!!! i agree though, seems like before B&T could easily understand each other…i wish they could get that back
Fantastic! Alice, for once, used her meddling powers for good! My previous assertion that Bette should make the first step was based on Bette’s infidelity being the launching point of their current situation. Of course, here, you put the ball in Tina’s court. As Alice said, they don’t listen to one another, and their communication skills were quite damaged from what we saw in the Pilot. I don’t even care who makes the first move! Maybe they’ll run into each other at one of the airports, but it’s long overdue for them to declare their undying love for one another and live happily ever after! Will we get another early post so we can see very quickly how you intend to reunite our girls??
Good chapter. Now let see Tina fight and win Bette back, thanks to Alice. Plesae post more, thanks!
Hello Steph, I have just caught up with these latest chapters. Thank you so much for this intriguing and delightful tale. It is brilliant to see the mind games that Tina and Bette have been playing begin to unravel and allow their true feelings to emerge. Sweet that Alice was the one to provide Tina with an honest appraisal of Bette’s recent behavior. Now the air is clear it is time for Tina to go get her woman. I can’t wait. Steph, you embody this well crafted story with love and understandong. Just perfect. More please as I can’t wiat to see Tina on the prowl and Bette as the hunted. Many thanks Your Loyal Fan.