Fan Fiction
This story has been set to a rating of PG-13. Age verification is required to proceed.
Seventeen Reasons Why – Eleven
Bette flinched slightly.
“I don’t know,” Bette shook her head.
“All I want is honesty Bette. I want you to be honest with me at the very least. The affair was because you weren’t happy with me? Is that why? If so then I don’t know how you could have expected me to welcome you back with open arms.”
“I didn’t think I was in love with you anymore,” Bette said monotone.
Her face was taut and her eyes haunted as she stared at Tina.
“I really…at that point I really thought what we had was gone, Tina. I just…I–you want honesty, right? Fine. Because you know I’ve thought about this. These past couple of days it’s all I’ve thought about. You and I weren’t connected the way we had been and it had been going on for years. Just slowly building up and then when our baby died things spiraled out of control.”
“You’re blaming me, then?” Tina asked the energy seeming to drain from her.
Bette shook her head empathically.
“No. I’m not. You didn’t make me cheat. All those things and all these feelings just bogged me down. I just wanted…freedom. I was scared about the baby, about being able to take care of a baby and you financially. Just the prospect of our whole lives changing scared me. And instead of talking to you about it I internalized it and thought that it would go away on its own. My reasoning wasn’t quite right. I made up excuses when I started spending more time with Candace. If I was in love with you I wouldn’t cheat. I always told myself that would be the only way. That I would never do what my father did to my mother. That if I felt the urge then I would’ve fallen out of love with the person I was with. So with Candace I assumed that it couldn’t be happening unless I wasn’t in of love with you.”
“So you fell out of love with me? When did that happen?” Tina felt compelled to ask.
“And so I put you in a box inside my mind,” Bette continued on as if Tina hadn’t spoken. “You know how I like to put people into boxes, right? Well that’s what I did. I put you in that box and went with what I thought I should do.”
Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.


Great Chapter Speed!!!! Thanks PPS
What a difficulty conversation to have – if I were Tina that would have been hard as hell to hear – but it is the closest version to what was shown in the scenes on the show – Bette fell out of love because of the loss and the pressure and because these two idiots couldn’t communicate for shit – Thank god you have them doing it now painful as it is. Thanks.
this was really really good explanation of the whole candace affair…i’ve read a lot of them and tried to explained it myself because the on the show tibette still didn’t talk about it…what you pointed out was really interesting and intense…it’s really a time for them just to talk about it and let past be past so they can be back together in a better place
Okay, I just caught up on all you posted on “Seventeen reasons why” and I just wanted to say, I absolutley love your writing. This chapter did drain me as much as it did Tina so, bravo for that! I just hope that you post soon, very soon!
Wow! An intense and long, long overdue conversation! I like your take on why the Candace thing happened; very plausible with what we know. Just wish they’d had the convo long ago and on the show as many others have said! And yes, Jenny is gonna get that a** whupping Bette promised to give her after she’d read the book! Hmm…is Candace gonna show up herself? That would be really deep! Would love to see how you handle that! Continue this marvelous tale soon! And I appreciate your efforts to write us a TiBette–I am sure it doesn’t just flow the way your BeLenas do!
Hey SR, Great to have Bette and Tina sharing this intimate conversation.These gals have a lot to work through but by taking the time and being honest with each other they can make it. This is a majpr step forwards for them so let the good times roll again. Thank you for this wonderful writing. Your Loyal Fan.
I really love this tale. Keep them talking and reconnecting…long overdue…it’s good they take their time and really understand what happened. Please let Bette be the wonderful bombastic bully she is so good at with Jenny and Candance, please let Tina see the fireworks she needs that.
The love never went away it just got buried under all the bad stuff that had gone on in their lives. Hopefully now the good stuff will unbury the their love and allow them to move forward which IMO should be as a family again.
a Belena, a Belena, and then TiBette! and i thuoght i was confused! Of course…you really haven’t gotten these two together! Love loved loved your recent updates. You such a great writer. AND I hope Bette kicks Jenny and Candace’s ass….can she? Please?
See, it’s things like that that make me wish that stupid inflatable dinghy Jenny was on had mysteriously deflated, miles from shore. Vicious little cow… gah! Anyway. They’ve started to scratch the surface of this, and I’m glad to see Bette is talking and apologizing sans groveling. Their next talk is going to be heavy… they still have to discuss that generic toenail-clipping McDude that Tina decided to shag. Ugh. Great as always, Speed. Thanks for the post.
Damn, their is just so much excess baggage these two are carrying around. It was wrong, but you can’t undo whats already been done, you have to let it go and move forwarded. Hopefully the love they have for each other will carry them through. I for one have complete faith in B&T. And I’m with pandamel, Bette so needs to kick Jenny’s ass.
Damn that wore me out just reading it. Okay, so one more chapter of drama ending with Bette kicking some ass, right? =D
That is one of the best explanations about that time that I have ever read. And I’m still stunned that Bette came for the visit…wow
OMG…How hot was that? I tell ya, I wanted to stunt double for Bette against that door…No joke!
nice 2 see they r growing up at last…