Fan Fiction
This story has been set to a rating of NC-17. Age verification is required to proceed.
The Laws of Attraction: Part Twenty Five
“Alice always goes back to her,” Dana said, looking away from Shane and pulling the edge of her bedspread into her lap to fold then unfold it mechanically. “How many times have we seen it happen, Shane? No matter what she says to us about how she won’t do it, she won’t go back to Gabby this time, she does it anyway. And even if the person she’s with tries to stop it from happening, it never works. Gabby wins in the end.” Biting down hard on her bottom lip, Dana said in horrible resignation, “I’m just making it easier this time, that’s all.”
“No, you’re just giving up, that’s all,” replied Shane angrily and the tennis player jerked her head up in surprise. Though they had been friends for years Dana couldn’t ever recall seeing the hair stylist truly upset with someone. She was such a calming and mellow influence, like the sane port in the storm and frankly it was a little off putting to hear her angry for once. Scowling deeply, Shane rose to her feet and shoved her hands deep into the pockets of her jeans. Looking at Dana with dark and glittering eyes, she said, “I thought you really loved her, you know? What you said to me that day, how I saw you act with her, it made me stop and think that maybe I had to take that chance myself because you did and you were happy. You were really in love. But maybe I was wrong, huh? Maybe it was a lie and you never loved Alice. I mean, look at your room,” Shane snorted disdainfully and pulled her hands out to wave at a nearby shelf filled with stuffed animals. “Maybe this is who you really are. Maybe you spent so much time in the closet Alice was like your high school romance and you thought you loved her but really you didn’t give a ***** because you’re willing to give up when it gets hard.”
Staring at her friend in shock, Dana felt herself becoming just as angry and she hissed, “I love Alice. And don’t you ever say otherwise.”
“If you love her then why are you giving up on her?” demanded Shane, stepping up to the bed, challenging the athlete in both her words and body language. “Why are you doing this?”
“I told you why!” Dana shouted, her voice cracking and the stress of situation showing up in the pained lines on her face, looking at Shane with an anguished expression. “Gabby always wins. What if I do it, huh, Shane?” demanded Dana, rising to her feet and meeting the other woman eye to eye. “What if I go to Alice and what if I don’t give up? What if I do all that, I lay it all out there, how much I love her, how much I need her, how much I really ***** feel I can’t live without her and then she goes and chooses Gabby again?” Blinking back the tears angrily and clenching her hands, Dana asked, “Where does that leave me? Right where I am now.” Squeezing her eyes shut, the brunette ducked her head. “It’s better this way.”
Sighing heavily, Shane stared at her friend, lost in her misery and whatever anger she managed to work up blew away like leaves in the wind. Pulling the other woman to her, Shane wrapped her up in a hug, hating herself as she heard the sound of Dana’s quiet sobs. “What if she doesn’t choose her?” she murmured into the crown of wavy brown hair. “That’s only what you’re scared might happen, Dane. Not what you know will really go down. If you do this… if you leave things like this you’re going to spend the rest of your life wondering about that. Wondering if you were right or wrong and if Alice would have chosen you if you had only had the courage to step up and ask her.”
“What if she says no?” whispered Dana, her voice and body trembling.
“Then at least you asked her, at least you know for sure that’s what she said and you can try to move on,” Shane answered, pulling back from their embrace and smiling softly as she pushed a lock of hair from Dana’s eyes. “You can’t do that if you leave it like this, Dane. There’s no way you’ll ever be able to move on and if you can’t do that, I don’t think you can even go back to being just friends with Alice like you would want.”
“You really think that?” asked Dana almost helplessly, rubbing at her nose with the back of her hand and peering up at Shane with watery eyes.
Her smile remaining, Shane moved away slightly and reached for a nearby box of kleenex, handing one to Dana who took it with a look of appreciation. “I don’t know, what do you think?” said Shane with overwhelming patience. “Do you think you could be friends with Alice if you were always wondering what could have been? Would she have chosen you?”
“I could do it,” murmured Dana quiet and defeated, making Shane’s heart sink until the athlete peered at her with a wry blue gaze and a tiny smile. “But it would really suck.”
“Yeah,” said Shane, laughing affectionately and forming an answering smile, her eyes crinkling up around the edges. “It really would.”
Releasing a shaky breath and running her hand through her tangled brown hair, Dana looked at Shane and still wearing her half smile, she said, “I need to do this, don’t I?”
“Yeah,” replied Shane softly, nodding her head. “You do.” Tilting her head in consideration, Shane smirked and poked her friendly lightly in the abdomen. “And you need to take a shower and change your clothes while you’re at it.”
“And get my hair cut?” Dana asked, lifting an eyebrow humorously.
“Nah,” rumbled Shane, tucking a lock of wavy brown hair behind the tennis player’s ear. “Your hair cut can wait for another day. You’ve got more important things to do.”
“I never thought there would come a day when I heard Shane McCutcheon say there were things more important than hair,” Dana said jokingly. She paused and her eyes reflected a solemn and heartfelt emotion as she gathered her friend up in another hug. “Thank you for this, Shane. Thank you so much.”
“You’re welcome,” murmured Shane in return, smiling as they pulled apart. Stepping backwards and making a playful wave at the door, she said, “Now get going! Take that shower and change those clothes and get your answer.”
Dana nodded her head quickly and pulled open her door to go running down the hallway and into the bathroom. The sound of her footsteps gaining Irwin’s attention and a few seconds after she shut the door to the bathroom he poked his head out of his office and locked eyes with Shane. For the second time that day they shared a silent moment, studying each other, but this time it was far from awkward. This time it was comfortable and wonderfully joyful as they realized that things might just turn out all right now.
—
Unlike most people in the free world, Alice considered herself lucky that she actually enjoyed her work. Though she really was loving her new position as a DJ at KCRW and having her own radio show she still loved her work at LA Magazine. It was true that she got a lot of flack and a good deal of teasing about her long standing best of lists for the magazine but she loved doing it all the same. Alice wasn’t someone who had these great aspirations for writing award winning and hard hitting journalism articles. She much rather be the person who writes the columns and pieces that readers look forward to with each new edition.
And she was that person, she had been that person for years at LA Magazine. The fan mail she got in about her best of lists weren’t over the top and gushing and coming in as huge tidal waves at a time but it was consistent. She would always get letters from people who enjoyed her work and would take the time to tell her so and that was enough for Alice.
Just knowing that someone out there in her reading audience liked what she was writing was enough for her to be happy in her work.
Since she was among the lucky few who liked her work, whenever Alice was feeling down about life in general she tended to bury herself in it. Which was what she was currently doing, chewing on her pen cap and staring at her iBook as she contemplated ideas for her best of article that featured local candy stores and other deliciously unhealthy eateries.
Places she really wanted to go to right now because the other thing she liked to do when she was feeling down was to eat food just like this. Lucky for her she could use work as an excuse to do precisely that. Contemplating what she should eat first, a brick of homemade fudge or a chocolate chip cookie pie, Alice didn’t hear the magazine’s longtime secretary, Tracy, call out her name three separate times. But she did hear it the fourth time. Mostly because by then Tracy was standing right next to her and tapping her on the top of the head.
“Hey,” said Alice, looking up at the other woman. “What’s up?”
“Someone with the last name of Fairbanks is here to see you,” Tracy informed in her usual chirping and happy tones. “She’s been waiting downstairs for a few minutes because–”
“Thanks, Tracy,” Alice said quickly, rushing to her feet and out of the office to head downstairs, thinking there was only one person who could be down there waiting for her.
Unfortunately, she was proven wrong when she entered the downstairs lobby with a ding of the elevator doors opening and was met by the sight of Sharon Fairbanks waiting patiently by the circular desk used by Tracy to greet guests.
“Sharon?” said Alice in definite confusion. “What are you doing here?”
“I’ve come to see you,” said Sharon, acting as if it was one of the most natural things in the world. She tilted her head and offered a warm smile. “Have lunch with me? There are some things I think we should discuss.”
“Okay,” Alice said dimly, unsure what to make of the situation. “Just let me get my purse.” She gestured to the elevator and started to move towards it. “I left it upstairs.”
“Nonsense, this will be my treat,” Sharon insisted, walking over to Alice and hooking their arms together to lead the blonde out of the offices of LA Magazine and into the bright light of day. “I know a charming little French bistro down the street. Would you like to give it a try? I’m sure you would like their wild mushroom tarts.”
“I love mushrooms,” said Alice faintly, not quite over the slight feeling of shock caused by finding Sharon and not Dana waiting for her in the lobby.
“I know,” said Sharon a little triumphantly, leading the walk down the street and towards the bistro which happened to be only a few buildings from their offices. “Dana told me once of your fondness for them.”
“Dana hates them,” Alice said, smiling at the memory of one of the athlete’s funnier rants against the food. “She calls them evil fungus and refuses to kiss me after I eat them.”
“That doesn’t surprise me,” Sharon remarked, chuckling and opening the door to the bistro to step back against it, allowing Alice to enter the restaurant first. It was a simple gesture, innate in its ingrained manners, and it was something the blonde had seen Dana do a hundred times herself. “When she was a little girl there was this wretched animated program about tiny creatures who lived inside mushrooms and used the same word to describe nearly everything in their conversations.” Sharon looked to Alice who wore a thoroughly amused expression and said matter factly, “She despised the show utterly. I even remember one incident where Dana shrieked on seeing it before changing the channel.”
“You tell me Dana hates The Smurfs,” said Alice in something close to awe, shaking her head at the strangeness that still completely fit the tennis player all the same. Despite herself, she couldn’t help that small feeling of happiness she always got when she found out something new about the brunette. They had been friends for such a long time that often she thought she knew everything about Dana. So when she was proven wrong and was given a new tidbit of information, Alice found herself ridiculously happy as a result. Just because it was something new about the woman she loved. “And Howie tells me she loves Morrissey,” Alice mused, chuckling. “I’m learning all of her entertainment predilections this week.”
“You didn’t know she listens to that wallowing balladeer?” asked Sharon, looking rather surprised. The greeter for the bistro arrived and she smiled warmly then said, “We’ll take a table for two please.” Nodding his head, the greeter led them through the myriad of tables and Sharon looked back to Alice. “I’ve suffered through endless hours of his singing when she was a teenager. I almost prefer Howie’s rap music because it isn’t laced with overdone misery.”
“The guy is depressing,” said Alice in agreement, sitting across from Sharon at the table and smiling nervously when the older woman fixed a serious gaze on her. “What is it?”
“When did Howie come to see you?” asked Sharon.
“Two days ago,” said Alice, hoping that she wasn’t getting the teenager into any trouble. On looking back at the encounter she was touched that he cared so much about his sister that he would take the time to try and fix their problems. “He came to see me with Gino.”
Sharon released a soft murmuring noise then she sighed and flipped open the menu. Studying it carefully, she remarked, “I’ve always wanted for them to be close.” Lifting her gaze, she smiled at Alice. “I did research on sibling rivalry and decided that they should be at least ten years apart to prevent the jealousies that often arise. My research backfired on me though,” Sharon revealed with twinkling eyes. “While they did fight, it the was harmless practical joking kind, but they also became close enough that I couldn’t ever punish one without gaining the wrath of the other.” Turning her attention back to the menu, Sharon said, “It doesn’t surprise me that Howie came to see you on Dana’s behalf. I expect that of him.”
“I was surprised,” said Alice quietly and when Sharon lifted her head to look at her with wide eyes that appeared almost insulted at her words she knew she had to explain. “I was surprised to see both of you. My family doesn’t do that type of thing. *****,” she gave a wry chuckle. “My family doesn’t even see each other on their birthdays and major holidays. So there’s no way they’d ever show up on your doorstep wanting to talk to Dana about my relationship with her. It’s nice though,” Alice said, focusing on the table and unfolding the napkin in front of her. “It’s nice that you guys actually care.”
There was silence and Sharon looked as if she wanted to reply but she stopped herself on noticing the arrival of their server. Their food and drink orders quickly placed, they were soon alone again and once they were, Sharon said, “Since you know that we care, I’m sure that you’re aware of why I’m here.”
“I can’t go to her,” said Alice in a bare whisper, averting her eyes and staring out the large windows of the restaurant and at the people walking by on the street. “If she wants to fix this she has to come to me, Sharon. I already told Howie the same thing.”
“You’re testing her,” said Sharon, her voice brittle in the accusation it held, blue eyes flashing angrily at the writer. “I’m not sure why but I had thought better of you.”
“I’m not testing her,” Alice said wearily, looking exhausted with the situation and having to explain herself over and over. “I just can’t keep doing this. It’s like I told Howie, I can’t keep chasing after Dana. I can’t live my life with her if I have to keep making her do everything, it’s like forcing myself on her and I won’t do that.” She met Sharon’s eyes and pleaded for some understanding. “I have to know she needs me too. Enough that she won’t do this again, that she won’t leave me at the first sign of trouble.” Swallowing the lump in her throat, Alice voice cracked as she said, “I love her too much. It would kill me to be with her and think she could leave again. There’s no way I can keep going through this, Sharon.”
She felt the caress of an elegant hand holding hers and then Sharon’s voice, cultured and low, filled her ears. “When Dana was younger we had a tree in our backyard. A large oak tree that was quite tall and she wanted to climb it but she was always afraid of falling.” Alice lifted her eyes up and looked at Sharon who was staring off to one side, her face lined in quiet happiness as she became lost in the memories. “For a week, every day after school she would go into the backyard and stare at the tree. Until one day Dana finally worked up the courage to climb it and once she did, she climbed until she was at the very top.” Sharon laughed fondly, recalling the sight of her daughter appearing amongst all of the leaves at the top of the tree looking much like the angel ornament they put on top of the Scotch Pine they got every Christmas. Turning her head and locking her gaze with Alice’s, she smiled in reassurance, squeezing her hand. “It might take my daughter longer than most people to work up the courage to go after what she wants but once she does find that courage, there isn’t anything in this world that can stop her.”
Her head dropping in a desperate nod, fighting back the tears that were forming, Alice once again felt the calming touch of elegant hands. This time they were wiping away her tears with an expensive napkin and when she looked up at Sharon she saw nothing but understanding and genuine care in her eyes.
“My daughter loves you,” Sharon murmured in tones that while were terribly kind were very clearly not up for debate. This was the truth as she saw it and anyone who tried to question it would most certainly get a piece of her mind. “She’ll come back to you, Alice. I promise it.”
Despite herself, Alice believed Sharon and for the first time in days she began to hope.
—
Patience wasn’t something that Gabby naturally possessed. She could make herself wait as the plans she made played out but she hardly enjoyed doing so. On the contrary, she would much rather go in and force the result she wanted to occur than sit back and wait for things to happen. But for the past two days she had forced herself to be patient.
There had been no contact with Alice on her part, she decided to wait for the air to clear. For time to pass and for the blonde to get over her initial anger at the situation before she went to her again. The only problem was that when Gabby went to Alice, she wasn’t at home.
Which is why she was standing outside Alice’s apartment door, leaning against the wall, arms folded over her chest and a bored look on her features when the elevator doors opened with a ding. Like all the times before, Gabby wasn’t greeted by the sight of Alice but unlike all those times before she recognized the person stepping off of the elevator.
“The tennis player,” said Gabby in supremely droll tones, lifting an eyebrow as Dana scowled and walked towards her. “You’ve decided to grace Alice with your presence, have you? I heard that you ran home to Mommy and Daddy.”
“What are you doing here?” Dana demanded.
“I’m waiting for the white rabbit,” replied Gabby, smirking at the confused look on Dana’s tanned features. Rolling her eyes, she scoffed with a chuckle, “You aren’t the brightest bulb in the cheap hanging chandelier, are you?”
“Alice doesn’t want to see you,” said Dana darkly, taking a somewhat ominous step towards Gabby. The screenwriter would’ve felt an urge to step backwards if she wasn’t already leaning against the wall with nowhere to go. “So just leave.”
“Right,” drawled Gabby, looking at Dana skeptically. “And how exactly would you know that when you haven’t seen or talked to her since that day you went running?” Dana opened her mouth to reply but Gabby waved her off and continued, “Never underestimate the power of dykes gossiping. That’s how I know you haven’t gone near Alice.” Releasing a noise of disdain, Gabby said, “Don’t act high and mighty with me. We’re both in the same pathetic dingy, tennis player. We don’t know what Alice is thinking and that’s the reason we’re here. To find out.” Tilting her head to one side, the screenwriter studied the other woman for a long moment. “Or maybe I’m wrong. Maybe you’re too ***** scared to actually hear that.”
“What did you say?” asked Dana, narrowing her eyes and her voice raising an octave.
“You heard me,” Gabby said simply. “All your life you’ve been too ***** scared to do anything. When in the ***** should this be any different? I’m going to win this race because you’re the type who doesn’t even show up to ***** compete.”
The athlete started to reply when the elevator doors opened with a ding and they heard someone say, “Dana? Did you lose your keys?” Moving in synchronization, Dana and Gabby turned to face Alice’s neighbor, Patty, who looked at them rather blankly. “Hey,” she gave her traditional greeting, frowning when she saw who was with Dana. She thought the bitchy brunette was long gone thanks to the athlete’s influence. Though Patty wasn’t the type to form instant opinions about things she could admit that she disliked some people on general principal. And after seeing the woman with Dana make Alice miserable several times with basic put downs, Patty disliked her based on just that. “You want me to call Alice?”
“No, I’ve got it,” said Dana, shooting Patty a reassuring smile and pulling the keys out her pocket. The truth is, she had been hoping to get rid of Gabby before she went inside the apartment to wait for Alice. But now it looked like she didn’t have a choice. Unlocking the door quickly, she scowled as Gabby pushed passed her go inside. Turning to Patty, she shot her another smile and said, “See you later.”
“Yeah,” said Patty quietly, watching the door close. “Later.”
Shoving the keys back into her pocket, Dana walked into the living room and found Gabby perched in the large stuffed chair, her left leg tucked under her right, looking completely at home. Scowling on seeing this, Dana sat down on the couch and glared at the screenwriter. “Alice isn’t something you can win,” she growled the words out. “She’s a person and not a cheap prize at a carnival.”
“People can be prizes because a prize is nothing but something that somebody somewhere wants to have,” Gabby responded knowingly, arching an eyebrow. “And I sure as ***** want to have Alice so what’s wrong with considering her a prize?” A smile quirking on her lips, Gabby chuckled. “I always did consider myself a Cracker Jacks girl.”
“She’s a person!” Dana shouted, her anger immediately getting the best of her as for just a moment she thought about the woman in front of her being with Alice again. Taking Alice away from her with smooth talk and charming smiles only to hurt her in the same way that she always did. “Stop talking about her like she’s a thing.”
“Would you rather we talk about you?” asked Gabby curiously, moving to untuck her left leg and pull it back so it was against her chest and she could rest her chin on its knee. “Why don’t we talk about you and how you never ***** try? Why don’t we talk about how I knew you were in love with Alice from the first time I saw you and how I also knew you wouldn’t do anything about it because you’re too ***** scared.” Blue eyes were bright and glittering but cold and clinical in the intelligence they held as Gabby went on, “Why don’t we talk about how you say you love Alice but you never do anything to prove it.”
“Don’t you say that to me,” said Dana, approaching Gabby and staring her down. “What have you ever done to prove it? You hurt her over and over again, you throw away the second chances she gives you like they’re garbage and you’re going to tell me I don’t do anything to prove I love Alice? How about the fact that I never hurt her like you? How about that?”
“Not hurting someone doesn’t prove you love them, it just proves you’re not an *****,” scoffed Gabby. “And yes, I’ll admit I’m an *****. But at least with me Alice knows where she stands. I always tell her how I feel. I tell her when she turns me on, when she doesn’t, when I love her, and when I’m pissed at her. You?” Gabby snorted and looked at Dana with disdain. “You loved her for ***** years and kept it to yourself like a goddamn chicken. How does that prove your love? That proves you’re selfish like me.”
“Don’t ever compare me to you,” hissed Dana dangerously.
“Why not?” asked Gabby, rising to the challenge and to her feet, meeting Dana’s hard stare and matching it with equal strength of emotion. “You are selfish. If I hurt Alice so much over the years and you love her so ***** more than me why the ***** didn’t you step up, huh? Why didn’t you tell her you felt that way? Because you’re a chicken, like I said. You were afraid of her turning you down so you just kept your mouth shut. Then what happened?” Gabby formed a slow smirk and drawled, “She came back to me. I went after her like you were too ***** afraid to do and she came back to me again and again while you sat on your angsty *****.” Stepping up to Dana and locking their eyes, she said, “You don’t deserve Alice because you don’t do anything to keep her. *****,” Gabby snorted. “You haven’t done anything to get her. She’s the one who came after you, right? She told you she was in love and that’s when you finally got your midget sized bout of courage and told her after how many years you loved her back. Wow! Aren’t you brave?” Gabby mocked, rolling her eyes and waving her hands about. “I might be an ***** who treats Alice ***** but at least she always knows what I feel.”
Though she loathed to admit it, Dana knew that Gabby was right about that. She had been inactive in that aspect of her relationship with Alice. Content to let the blonde lead and for her to always follow. But that was going to change as of this moment. From now on she wouldn’t let Alice have doubts or ever wonder about how she felt, Dana would make sure that the writer knew with everything in her that she loved her. That she would always love her and she would always be there, for as long as Alice would have her.
“She’s going to know how much I love her,” said Dana strongly, her expression resolute and unwavering as she stared at Gabby. “I’ll make sure of it.”
For a response Gabby looked at Dana with an utterly cynical expression, opening her mouth to reply but stopping as she heard the sound of the front door opening. Moving together, Dana and Gabby turned to see Alice who stopped in her the middle of removing her coat to stare at them with wide eyed surprise. She clearly had not been expecting to see either of them and certainly not them both together.
“Alice,” Dana and Gabby said her name in similarly eager tones, each wanting to get the jump on the other and as she watched them run to her side, she knew that this was it.
The decision had to be said.
To be continued…
Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.


(15 votes, average: 4.73 out of 5)
thank you for this chapter. You managed to hit every emotion and really made me want to bitch slap gabby, perhaps afterwards I’d want to make out with her because she’s just that kind of person. Love the morrisey references, brilliant and true–and the exchange between Shane and Dana was spot on. Actually loved the interactions between all the characters….now I’m going to hole up and wait another 2 weeks for your brillance to grace my computer screen!
hmm…who to chose who to chose?!! Gosh…always leaving us with cliffhangers..can’t wait for the next post, loving the story like always.
amazing chapter! i really love this story and for the first time when i was reading the Dana/Gabby exchange at the end i thought ‘wow, i would REALLY like to see this acted out’ fantastic! Update soon :D
You don’t need me to tell you what an excellent writer I think you are…you’ve got the award to tell you that already! But I’m going to say it anyway because you ARE a terrific writer ! I love how you detailed Gabby’s character, so realistic! loved it! Cannot wait for the next update.
Every interaction in this chapter was great: I loved the parts with Shane and Irwin, and Alice and Sharon (and of course Dana and Shane). And it really makes me wish Gabby would be around again in S3 (but only if written by you). . . Now, come on Dana!
I am soo looking foward to your next chapter. I hope it sooonnnn, I’m going out of my mind waiting. LOL
i’m sorry- i’ve been enjoying this tale from the beginning and have been really lazy about thanking you– you write so lovely i tend not to worry about telling you. you hear and capture all of them so well– loved your Irwin/Shane exchange– really sweet. thanks for your posts.
another great chapter can’t wait for the next one
Excellent as always.
This is Alice’s enternal struggle, Dana or Gabby. I’ve always enjoyed your writings, you have the amazing ability to keep us hanging on chapter after chapter. I can’t believe I’m going to say considering how big of a Dana I am but I can’t help but what would happen if Alice does pick Gabby.
Don’t tell me I have to wait 15 days to read the next one :( Well, waiting for the next one. This is really, really good.
Oh the angst!!! I’m so hooked on this story…don’t make us wait too long for an update!:)
god I can’t wait to see what alice has to say so please post soon I love your story
I’m first!!! Yippee! Please post soon! I’m addicted to your story!
Everything everyone else said goes for me also, It’s hard coming up with new ways of saying great, wonderful, ect. Can’t wait for the next chapter, even though I know I have to.
dear sweet jyasus i am dying here im addicted to this story like it were a soap or something. Loved The Smiths references i recently went to see a play with all the music in it! BRILLANT