Fan Fiction
This story has been set to a rating of PG-13. Age verification is required to proceed.
Life and Love and Why – 40
Tina shook her head. "I never promised to come home. Mom and Dad misunderstood the situation, and I’ve apologized to them for that. But I’m not apologizing for Bette."
"Do you even understand what being in a relationship with her means?"
"Yes. Yes, Cathy, trust me: I’ve heard it all." Tina replied. "I’ve heard everything anyone has to say about it, and I still choose to be with her. And why does that even matter? You were my family. You’re supposed to support me, whoever it is I’m dating."
"The way you all supported me while I was dating Greg?" Cathy retorted. "What was your nickname for him? Old Reliable?"
Tina sighed.
"You all thought he was too boring to even bother with," Cathy reminded.
"But we didn’t take it out against you, or him," Tina remarked. "So don’t try to make a comparison."
Cathy looked at her, and tried another tack. "Tina. We’re not a liberal family. And Mom’s a public figure. What do you think people were going to say if it came out that you were dating a woman?"
"That Mom supports the choices of her children." Tina said sharply. "What it comes down to is that both you and mom put your own interests over that of the family. And, after all that, you blamed me for what happened to the family. When you confronted Ned, and he chose to get a job in another country so that he won’t have to deal with what was happening, you blamed me for giving him the chance to make that choice. That if it weren’t for my decisions, he wouldn’t feel the need to get away. Mom can throw me out, and you can cut me off, but I am not going to take the fall for what happened to the family because you and Mom told me to go. That wasn’t me, Cathy. I didn’t have a choice. You did. And you chose to back up Mom when she decided she didn’t want me around anymore."
Cathy shook her head, immediately dispelling Tina’s rant. "You don’t get it, do you?’
Tina gave her a confused look.
"Mom was going to sweep it all under a rug, and pretend none of that happened. She overreacted, and we all knew that. But when Christmas came, she was going to call you right up and ask if you were coming." Cathy told her. "She was going to pretend you didn’t bring home your girlfriend, and pretend Bette’s just a friend you really, really like. She was going to do that selective memory thing that she always pulled out, just for you."
Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.

HEY TD, Great addition as CAthy and Tina finally talked and got some understanding of each other. This is a compromise for both these women as they hold strong beliefs and are unable to the wood for the years.Jealousy has played a big part in this dislike from Cathy’s side and now Tina knows this.For the sake of their families it is a time to let sleeping dogs lie and move forward.Only by communicating can we ever hope to change minds and ideas.I can’t wait to gets Bette’s take on all this as her own relationship with Kit has been stormy over the years.This is just a delight to devor. More please from Your Loyal Fan.
Wow! What a great chapter…There is no doubt that Cathy is Tina’s older sister…Tina really seemed to grasp this conversation at a very deep level I just hope it translates to Tina and Bette’s relationship…PPS
Great insight into sibling relationships. Very well written.
Brava! as usual. It was hard to wrap my head around Cathy’s reasoning until that last part – being the unremarkable one – had to hurt. She and Tina found common ground. Good stuff. Thanks! PPS.
I can understand Cathy’s jealousy over her sister and brothers attention, but not to the length that she took it. I hope that they will at least be on speaking terms and what about Ned? What will he say about this Cathy issue.
Wow that awesome and great talk!
wow great chapter
Is your twitter ID, “Tiff_Duke?” You can cut the tension with a knife between these two sisters. At least, honesty is finally told to each other. Deep stuff…Cathy…behind the scenes…wanting to have her own voice…by trying to take away Tina’s. Well written! Can’t wait for the next one!
Twitter, okay… I’d check if I knew the page to look for. I wonder if anyone’s tweeted a fic yet. So… Cathy. She seems to be holding a bit of resentment, that she’s always been in the background, and only got the role of “eldest”. After childhood, that’s not exactly Tina’s or anyone else’s fault that it’s where Cathy stayed, is it? I hope their truce one day develops into something a bit more meaningful, cos the two of them don’t really seem to know anything about the other. Great update, thanks tiff.
Thank you for the update, always a pleasure to read.
Maybe I gotta reread this, but I think I now which side of the fence I fall on wrt Cathy and it ain’t the good one. The motivation for her actions seems so catty and horrible, especially if she knew her family could have reconciled and instead chose to keep them all apart for 10 years… I had felt sorry for her, but now I really, really, really dislike her. I know all about fighting with siblings, but it’s not up to you to teach them anything (especially once they’ve reached adulthood). I’ll reread, anyway, cuz maybe I read this wrong. Thanks, tiff! A pleasure, as usual
very erudite…and yea tina has definitely played the background to bette; nonetheless tina is the stronger one. its time let go of the past=it can only contaminate the present. thx
It´s amazing Cathy hasn´t imploded over the past decade – is she just a little more calculating than Tina gives her credit for – she seems way too calm and controlled . . now is it just me or did the computer eat part of a section on page 3. Great update, thanks.
It’S good to see the reasons behind Cathy’s behaviour. It just isn’t only black and white.I hope to see more soon.
good update…was an interesting conversation
Excellent chapter. Thank you.
So, Cathy allowed Tina and her mother to remain at odds for all these years because she was jealous that Tina got more attention than her? She sounds like one bitter and angry individual. I’m glad they have agreed to at least act civil with each other but I don’t think Tina should ever let her guard down with Cathy. She’s a back stabber.
Amazing Chapter!!! What Cathy did was so wrong. Tina and Bette need to watch there backs. Thank you PPS
great chapter as usual, the dialog was perfect, love this story
i love family dynamics and child placement within families. it was an excellent dialogue of that. thx