Fan Fiction

    This story has been set to a rating of PG-13. Age verification is required to proceed.

    Age Verification

    I am years of age as of today, November 19, 2026

    Enter your current age into the field provide above. Stories with a rating of R or NC-17 may contain material not suitable for children. LesFan requires that all individuals wishing to read these stories confirm they are of at least 17 years of age. LesFan uses the MPAA rating labeling system for all stories.

    LesFan will also make a best attempt to filter profane words in stories that are not rated R or NC-17 unless the individual confirms they are of at least 17 years of age.

    LesFan uses the following rating scale for stories.






    Submit

    Life and Love and Why – 40

    "Why…"

    "Because you don’t cast off your favorite, Tina." Cathy told her matter-of-factly. "All it was going to take was one phone call from you, and she would have forgotten everything she’d said."

    Tina blinked, feeling like she’d just been slapped in the face.

    Cathy didn’t notice the expression on her sister’s face, continuing. "And that wasn’t fair, because she did say those things, and she meant them. Probably more than I did. I knew you never stopped to think about what it would mean if you shacked up with Bette Porter, and you had to understand. Did I step over the line? Maybe."

    "No." Tina cut in, snapping out of her stunned stupor. "No. Not ‘maybe’. You went too far. You don’t get to play innocent, Cathy, because I was cut out of our family for a decade because you didn’t want to have a sister who’s gay. Because that was going to ruin your image, and reputation."

    Cathy leaned back in her seat. "What does it matter, anyway? You’re here, Ned’s here. Mom and Dad are so happy to have you two back. What does it matter what I think, what I have to say?"

    "Because you may not like me and Ned very much, but we’re part of the same family, Cathy. And you may hate it even more, but Bette’s a part of mine, too. And you need to figure out if how you feel about me, or Bette, or about having a sister who’s gay is worth going through what Ned and I went through for the past few years." Tina held her gaze. "Because Ned and I have clawed our way back into this family. And we’re not giving it up just because you’re ‘uncomfortable’."

    Cathy looked at her, with a new air of resignation about her. She took a deep breath. "It’s not just Mom and Dad, you know."

    Tina lifted an eyebrow.

    "Paul was the smart one. Ned was the jock. You were the one most likely to succeed." Cathy said softly, glancing down. "I was the eldest."

    Tina paused, trying to follow Cathy’s thread.

    "Ask Mom, Dad, or any of their friends, and they can tell you exactly what the three of you were good at. What made you so great." Cathy lifted her gaze to meet her younger sister’s. "You, especially. Everybody cared about what you were going to do. They probably still do."

    Page 4 of 512345

    Comments

    1. HEY TD, Great addition as CAthy and Tina finally talked and got some understanding of each other. This is a compromise for both these women as they hold strong beliefs and are unable to the wood for the years.Jealousy has played a big part in this dislike from Cathy’s side and now Tina knows this.For the sake of their families it is a time to let sleeping dogs lie and move forward.Only by communicating can we ever hope to change minds and ideas.I can’t wait to gets Bette’s take on all this as her own relationship with Kit has been stormy over the years.This is just a delight to devor. More please from Your Loyal Fan.

    2. Wow! What a great chapter…There is no doubt that Cathy is Tina’s older sister…Tina really seemed to grasp this conversation at a very deep level I just hope it translates to Tina and Bette’s relationship…PPS

    3. Brava! as usual. It was hard to wrap my head around Cathy’s reasoning until that last part – being the unremarkable one – had to hurt. She and Tina found common ground. Good stuff. Thanks! PPS.

    4. I can understand Cathy’s jealousy over her sister and brothers attention, but not to the length that she took it. I hope that they will at least be on speaking terms and what about Ned? What will he say about this Cathy issue.

    5. Is your twitter ID, “Tiff_Duke?” You can cut the tension with a knife between these two sisters. At least, honesty is finally told to each other. Deep stuff…Cathy…behind the scenes…wanting to have her own voice…by trying to take away Tina’s. Well written! Can’t wait for the next one!

    6. Twitter, okay… I’d check if I knew the page to look for. I wonder if anyone’s tweeted a fic yet. So… Cathy. She seems to be holding a bit of resentment, that she’s always been in the background, and only got the role of “eldest”. After childhood, that’s not exactly Tina’s or anyone else’s fault that it’s where Cathy stayed, is it? I hope their truce one day develops into something a bit more meaningful, cos the two of them don’t really seem to know anything about the other. Great update, thanks tiff.

    7. Maybe I gotta reread this, but I think I now which side of the fence I fall on wrt Cathy and it ain’t the good one. The motivation for her actions seems so catty and horrible, especially if she knew her family could have reconciled and instead chose to keep them all apart for 10 years… I had felt sorry for her, but now I really, really, really dislike her. I know all about fighting with siblings, but it’s not up to you to teach them anything (especially once they’ve reached adulthood). I’ll reread, anyway, cuz maybe I read this wrong. Thanks, tiff! A pleasure, as usual

    8. very erudite…and yea tina has definitely played the background to bette; nonetheless tina is the stronger one. its time let go of the past=it can only contaminate the present. thx

    9. It´s amazing Cathy hasn´t imploded over the past decade – is she just a little more calculating than Tina gives her credit for – she seems way too calm and controlled . . now is it just me or did the computer eat part of a section on page 3. Great update, thanks.

    10. So, Cathy allowed Tina and her mother to remain at odds for all these years because she was jealous that Tina got more attention than her? She sounds like one bitter and angry individual. I’m glad they have agreed to at least act civil with each other but I don’t think Tina should ever let her guard down with Cathy. She’s a back stabber.

    Leave a Reply