Fan Fiction
This story has been set to a rating of PG-13. Age verification is required to proceed.
Provocations Linger- Chapter Five (revisited and revised)
The steward returned with their coffee and desert as Bette tried to formulate her thoughts. There were a thousand things she’d like to tell Tina. Questions she’d like to ask. But one memory had haunted Bette more than the others. They had never talked about it. Bette had never had a chance to apologize. She wondered if Tina would be angry if she brought it up.
Tina observed this mental battle and was beyond curious. She waited for Bette to make up her mind.
Finally, Bette appeared to exhale as she turned to her.
“Have you ever told anyone about… that night?” Bette watched Tina, trying to hold her eye. “The night after-“
Tina understood the question.
“Have you?” she asked quietly.
Bette shook her head. “No. No one.”
“I figured that,” Tina bit her lip. “I thought for a while that I might talk to someone, a therapist probably. I was really confused and needed some answers and I knew you couldn’t give them to me.”
Bette stared at the back of the seat in front of her.
“Why do you do that?” she asked turning to Tina.
“You always give me an out. You did it when we talked about the cheating too.
“I give you an out?” Tina questioned.
“Yes. Instead of making me offer at least SOME explanation for my behavior, you dismiss me, assuming I either won’t or can’t explain myself. Why don’t you demand an answer from me?”
“I know you Bette. I can promise you I’ve spent a lot more time analyzing your reasons for raping me than you have and I still don’t understand it.”
Bette winced at the word ‘rape,’ Did Tina really consider what happened that night ‘rape’?
“I’ve thought about it Tina. I’ve thought about it plenty.”
Tina sighed, watching Bette for a moment before she answered her.
“You’re right. I don’t ask you for answers Bette. What could you possibly tell me that won’t make me angry all over again? That’s not how I want to feel right now. That night isn’t something I can get ‘a little bit’ angry about Bette.”
Bette’s insides churned. Afraid to say anything, she sat mute. Tina was right, what could she possibly say?
Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.



(44 votes, average: 3.25 out of 5)
Glad to have you back! I really love this story.
Such a difficult conversation, when there’s differing recollections of what happened. thanks for posting
I remember the pages and pages of debate we had on TWOP over that supercharged word. Tempers flared, lines were crossed, people got bounced from the site for their inflammatory rhetoric. Rape. There, you said it, and I’m proud of you for going there. So many years later, can we cooly reflect on the passions of that night? Wow, what a way to end a season!!! Bette and Tina wrecked on the shores of infidelity! Season One was great, even with the Marcus Allenwood’s stupid girlfriend and Jenny’s mushroom trip. It was great, I tell you! You’re bringing it back. Thanks!
” The dominance of the act had aroused her and she had allowed herself to view it as sexual rather than controlling.” – interesting to finally see what was going through their minds at that time – wow
This was such a hard scene to watch in season 1 and it is still hard to remember it this far out. It brings up such uncomfortable feelings still. This conversation was great. Thanks for bringing this story back!
What an excellent chapter. The way you wrote about the rape scene was extraordinary. So complex, and so subjective. I’m really loving reading this story.
Wow this was a hard conversation. I, too, shuttered at the word ‘rape’. It is so hard, I remember at that time a lot of conversation going on around whether that was or was not rape. What I do know is that the conversation was hard in this chapter and will continue to be hard. You’ve got me hooked, amazing writing, and thank you!
This was the chapter that got me so hooked on your story in the first place. When Tina used the word rape, I remember thinking, What?! And then I went through the scene in my mind. You’ve written this so well, from both perspectives…I can’t wait for the rest of the conversation. Fantastic writing!! Thank you!!
I just have one question, you are going to finish it? I remember reading the first post and you left us hanging. please tell me we’re going to get a good ending
I think this story remains one of the most thoughtful and sensitive on the site. Glad you’re reposting.
that was the hardest scene to watch in season 1, so well done…the way you wrote about it brought back all those painful memories for them both but if they will survive that, they should be okay, right? i hope so :)
Awesome story and update. Thank you for posting. Excellent!