Fan Fiction
This story has been set to a rating of G. Age verification is required to proceed.
Sugar and Spice ~ Chapter 5
“But why?”
“I don’t know. Maybe I should have done something more than just kissing her in the playground and asking her to be my valentine forever and ever. She wiped her lips and told me she hated me.”
“So you would have done something else?”
“Well, now when I give her roses and ask her to be my valentine, she always says yes,” Bill answered as he bent down and kissed the top of his daughter’s head. “And you are my second valentine forever and ever.”
~~
Porter residence
Bette’s homework had been perfect and she had correctly spelled every word in her father’s quiz. She now sat in the room’s second leather club chair, the one that matched the one in which her father sat on the other side of a small table. The chair was too big – Bette’s legs were too short to bend at the end of the seat and too long to stick straight out in front of her. Every night, right before Bette settled into the large chair and joined her father to read quietly, sitting side by side, Melvin Porter would tap the chair’s seat and, once Bette had sat, he would stuff pillows behind his daughter’s back so that she could settle comfortably in place.
Almost every week, Bette’s father bought her a new book he had selected. Bette would dutifully read the selection. Sometimes the story was tedious. Sometimes the book was too simple. Sometimes, Bette struggled to read it, repeatedly rising from her chair to look up words in the large dictionary that sat on her father’s desk. Now, though, Bette was completely immersed in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. Every time she slipped the volume from its spot in the boxed set, she smiled at the remaining books, knowing that she had so much more to read. Sometimes, she would slip from the set one of the volumes she hadn’t yet read and glance at the illustrations. She convinced herself that she wasn’t cheating by reading ahead because she made certain that she didn’t look at any of the words.
Her father’s choice had delighted but surprised her. He was not a man who valued fantasy but he had explained that she should pay attention to the Christian messages. Bette wasn’t sure if she had found any and hoped that her father wouldn’t question her.
That night, Bette wasn’t focused on her reading, although she loved the book. Instead, she was trying to sense what would be a good time to ask her father the questions that had had plagued her since that afternoon.
She let a few opportunities go by, hoping to pick the perfect moment. When that moment didn’t come and she realized that it was getting late, she finally spoke
“Daddy?”
Bette watched as the fact that she had spoken registered in her father’s consciousness.
He looked up “Yes, Bette,” Melvin replied, giving his daughter his entire attention.
Bette had rehearsed her questions in her head. “Daddy, why is there a Valentine’s Day?”
“It is more accurate to refer to it as St. Valentine’s Day.”
Bette was genuinely confused, “St. Valentine’s?”
“It is a religious holiday for an early Christian martyr, though it is uncertain which since there were several ‘Valentines,’ that has been twisted into a holiday by the greeting card, flower, candy and restaurant industries, forcing people to spend money to publicly demonstrate what should remain private emotions.”
Melvin’s voice had become terse, and Bette knew he was annoyed. Yet, she had to continue because what her father said had confused her. She thought she remembered her father giving her mother presents on St. Valentine’s Day. “Twisted?”
“Contorted.”
“I thought people gave candy and flowers on St. Valentine’s Day.”
“Only foolish people.”
Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.

See, I got the Melvin Porter version of an explanation for St. Valintine’s Day but with the assurance that it is perfectly acceptable to be foolish when it comes to expressing love. Ah, to be a kid again =) Thanks Spumoni!
I see Melvin has a broken heart somewhere
this story is so cute, does bette have a mom or just melvin… i hoep she does… looks like tina’s dad is a big kid himself… pps
such different households, i don’t envy Bette at all…is Tina going to give her roses or kiss her on the playground? LOL
Love this story, Spumoni! And no, it isn’t saccharine at all, far from it. Rather, it’s like a truly delicious, tastebud-teasing dessert… lemon sorbet… or oatmeal cookies… or Irish Coffee… or of course spumoni :-)
I think I like daddy Kennard’s version of Valentines Day better. I would have loved to have half of Bette’s brain power, only half because she needs at least half of it to survive herself.
The girls want to know about v-Day, and what it all means. And Tina’s mother and father meet the same age as our girls, but no one acted on the feelings until 12 years later, interesting.
If this had NC-17 methinks you’d be turned in for literary child pornography. :P
Oh no. I have a feeling someone is going to get hurt soon. Melvin is such a fuddy duddy. :(
This is just darling. And they’re both thinking about the other being their valentine. Sweet and lovely. More please. Thanks for posting.
Melvin Melvin Melvin, let her be a kid please. The story is so cute, love the interaction between bette and Tina. Can’t wait to see them back to school lol. PPVS
This story is just so very precious. Thank you. Love it!
Melvin is a nightmare.PPS
I like how you presented the contrast between the families of little TiBette, Spumoni. One is stiff and highly intellectual while the other one is more playful and expressive. Would feisty Tina be brave enough to follow her father’s daring Be-my-valentine-forever-and-ever kiss in the playground tactic or the much safer giving of flowers? Oh, this is going to be so much fun to read. Btw, I think the more appropriate rating for this story is not PG but SO, as in Sugar Overload. =) Thanks a bunch for my sugar fix today, Spumoni! Cheers! =)
OK, no NC-17 for sex, but you really should consider the violence you’ve portrayed in earlier chapters. Judging by the bruised shins I think a PG is at least in order. Alas that Melvin is so intent on he and his daughter being smart that it makes him stupid. And no fun.
Hey Spumoni, What a treat you deliver. this was most definitely a case of Kennard sweetness versus Porter spice.These words just roll off the screen and paint a wonderful picture.It was funny to have Tina’s parents meeting while in third and second grade.Perhaps history is repeating itself.This is just a joy to read.Thank you so much.Your Loyal Fan.
Hey S, I’m just here to collect my ”20% off coupon for a therapy session that covers childhood angst.”… (see? we do read your author’s notes. If you need a further test, next time include your credit card # w its expiry date… ;-)
Ah yes, “The Chronicles of Narnia.” That was one of my favs as a kid…giggled when you wrote about Bette looking ahead at the many other books at the illustrations but not reading so it’s not cheating. That’s what I did too!!!! Clever contrasting of family dynamics. One can only hope it doesn’t warp our mini-B, too much…or hurt mini-T in her attempt of first love. 5-star rating for SC – Super Cute!