Fan Fiction
This story has been set to a rating of PG-13. Age verification is required to proceed.
Only Ever You – Chapter 2
“You can say that again” Brenda’s eyes shifted to Tina who understood the hidden meaning behind her words and lowered her head, a deep crimson coloring her cheeks.
Bette watched the exchange with confusion and irritation, arching an eyebrow in their direction. Just what did that comment mean?
“So, what are you doing here?” She asked Brenda before her souring mood could get the better of her.
“Aside from the obvious?” Brenda teased with a smirk, choosing to ignore the glare she received from Bette. In high school, she had never been able to resist pushing the brunette’s buttons whenever she had the chance. It seemed that the 7 years that had passed bore no exception, “I’m here to see my favorite bartender”
She smiled sensually and leaned across the bar, gazing lustfully at Tina who in turn blushed a deeper shade of red. Bette watched in a mixture of disbelief and horror, her own face matching Tina’s shade though hers was due to either anger or possibly a result of the warm temperature in the bar. Bette was leaning towards the latter.
Brenda was in the process of reaching to take one of Tina’s hands in hers when Bette caught herself about to take a menacing step forward. She instead steeled herself in place, clenching her jaw at the possessive nature currently coursing through her. She shouldn’t be jealous, she had no right to be nor did she want to be. Her history with Tina had ended 7 years ago and Bette hated that she had to constantly remind herself of the fact.
Tina discreetly pulled out of reach and used the hand Brenda had been reaching for to tuck a lock of hair behind her own ear. She seemed uncomfortable in her own shoes, her eyes landing everywhere but on Bette.
“So, Bette” Brenda continued to lean on the bar as she angled her body to get a better view of the brunette, Tina’s rejection clearly hadn’t fazed her. “I’m sure you want to go back to your friends”
The message was clear, Brenda was eager to spend some time alone with Tina and Bette was more than willing to deprive her of that. They were rivals, it’s what they did. There was nothing more to it than that. Honest.
Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.


Yeah, new chapter!
I was so happy to see an update to this story!!
Oh no, poor girls. I think we’ve all been in a scenario similar to this one where you imagine reconnecting with someone only to have things turn out in the exact opposite way of what you intended! I hope Bette decides to stay in town longer but either way I know nature will run it’s course for these two, just have to watch it play out! :)
PPS
Hi! Thank you for the chapter!
I think maybe Bette needs sometimes think before she speaks, because i don’t understand how she can tell something like that if she wanted at least friendly relationship with Tina.
Brenda won this round, Bette’s brain lost.
Waiting for the next!
Thanks for the post, enjoyed it, more please!
SG
Hi LxD:
Thanks for this new chapter, the introduction, and the two first chapters are excellent.
I’ve been reading your other stories too, but this is the first time I have the opportunity to write a comment. I like this story very much, as the former readers commented this looks a bit like a ‘deja vu’, like a memory from our own lives. How many times full of hopes we find someone emotionally very important from our past and at the same time you realize that it is forbidden fruit.
Anyway, Bette is still a little hurt and perhaps she fell in Brenda’s trap speaking the wrong words in front of Tina. But I hope she will stay longer in town.
Another question is, why Tina didn’t do more of herself, I mean no disrespect for working as a bartender, which is a very respectable job (indeed something I like) but I thought she has other goals when she finished high school; was it because Bette left her? It was something related to her family? Anyway, I will really love to know more about Tina’s life since she ended high school.
Thank you very much for the chapter and pps.
P
First time commenters always hold a special place in my heart :) I like to think that everyone has that one person from their past that can just turn their entire world upside down. Probably my inner romantic’s wishful thinking lol So many questions, I love it ! I promise all will be revealed in time so stay tuned ! Thanks for commenting ❤️
So i think Tina decline Bette’s marriage proposal back after school prompt? Yeah, thats why Bette still hurt? But what about Tina, Bette don’t think that she hurting too when Bette left her without even explanation and went to the college?
Hi LxD,
So happy to see a new chapter!
Can i slap Brenda out of the Planet to a country very far away, she is so annoying and Bette had a point in what she said to her.
I can understand Tina’s pain, but did she think that Bette’s life stood still in those seven years?
It is oblivious they need to have a honest talk before they can move on, and Bette, Emma will never be the woman you will spend eternity with, how sad and angry she and Tina need to talk it out.
Melvin is and will be in my mind always a incredible cruel, heartless man, i am wondering if he has anything to with Tina’s refusal. But on the other hand it could be something else, maybe family, sickness?
How did Tina end up as a bartender, no disrespect, but there must be a reason very important that she works for Kit.
Oh, so many questions and little answers, please don’t let us hanging for long!!!
I promise not to ! The next chapter is well underway. I have a busy weekend coming up but I will try to post ASAP :)
Really like this story, just wonder what dirty lie Melvin told Tina as to Bette’s absence and leaving and not saying goodbye. Evil old bastard. Hopefully they will get together before Bette has to leave, Thanks for posting.
Excellent start !!
So that what happened at the prom night. Tina refused Bette’s proposal. No wonder Bette felt heartbroken after that night.
Please don’t tell me that Tina and Brenda have already become a couple? (The news would break Bette’s heart all over again). But she was an ass when she told Brenda about her “success” in the big town with beautiful girlfriend in front of Tina. :( well if Bette could move on, why should Tina put her life on hold. :(
Can’t wait to read the update, please post soon Liah.
And, tks for the new chapter :)
So glad to see an update !
I had the same questions as everyone else so I won’t ask but I noticed that “Al” (the one at the bar not Alice) was mentionned a couple of time, is it someone important in your story or a random guy ?
Please be kind by posting real quick !
He’s just a random regular at the bar :) I’m sure I’ll use him again but not for anything more than comic relief